just writing.
by Georgia
This is a long rambling update, much more about me than about Elsa’s progress. Just wanted everyone to be forewarned! Hopefully I can figure out a way to blog non-Elsa updates without filling up everyone’s email boxes. I’m hoping to do some blog rearranging so that Elsa updates are in one place and my other ramblings are elsewhere – I should have stuck with CaringBridge! Much like some people like to rearrange the furniture in their house, I like to rearrange my blogs, I guess.
I think that anyone who blogs about their children/family goes through this crisis eventually. Am I doing the right thing by sharing our life so openly? Am I putting my family at risk? Is this safe? Why am I writing here? When Elsa is grown-up enough to read this stuff, will she find her mother’s candor horrifying? Will she feel exploited? Will she feel that I invaded her privacy without her consent? I thought about these questions before, but some recent events have got me spiraling again – wondering if I’m doing the right thing.
I’ve mentioned here before, but I’ve been semi-active on the Leukemia & Lymphoma Society discussion boards. Soon after Elsa was diagnosed, while I was furiously googling, “My kid has cancer,” I stumbled on the discussion boards and they were such a relief. Families from all over the world, discussing all the things that my non-cancer friends couldn’t help me with: vincristine-related neuropathy, neurontin dosage, morphine, clinical trials, ER procedures, what to pack for the hospital, etc. It was a wealth of information that I desperately needed. My first post was something to the effect of “My toddler has leukemia and won’t stop screaming – Help!” I got a few emails from other parents, offering support, condolences, and hope. One mom, in particular, sent me some valuable information regarding pain control and a link to her Caring Bridge site, where she wrote about the last 2.5 years of her daughter’s treatment. Those pictures of Emma Grace – off treatment, healthy, vibrant, and with beautiful shoulder-length hair (!), were like crack to me. I would sit there at my screen, after my steroided-out, limping, screaming toddler had finally succumbed to sleep – I would sit there and stare at the little slide-show of Emma Grace’s pictures. I would stare longer than you are supposed to stare at a stranger’s child and cry and try and imagine the unfathomable possibility that Elsa might look like that some day. I would force J to come over to the computer and cry, “Look! Look! That’s Emma Grace! She’s better! Elsa could look like that some day!”
Emma Grace’s mom and another mother of a child with ALL have become my friends through the internet. Certainly not friends in the traditional sense, especially since we’ve never met, but people who I hold in my thoughts and with whom I correspond – sometimes about cancer and sometimes not. I have stayed active enough on the boards too, responding to parents’ questions with whatever knowledge I’ve gained over the past 9 months. Occasionally, I still ask questions myself and I always receive timely, thoughtful replies. Recently, though, there was an incident on the discussion boards that made me reconsider the time I’ve spent there. I won’t delve too deeply into the story, because it’s pretty long and very sad, but I’ll try to give a brief overview.
One of the mothers on the boards has been posting since before I even joined up back in July. She had a really tragic story and her daughter passed away from ALL early this year, after a horrific fight with many, many complications. Soon after the child’s death, the mother gave birth to premature twins, one of which had a heart defect requiring surgery. Again, very soon after, this same mother was diagnosed with advanced breast cancer. Each step of the way, it all seemed too much to bear. Everyone on the boards would respond with something to the effect of “We are praying for you. We don’t know why your family would be stricken with such misfortune.” She never asked for money – only prayers and support.
Then, just a few weeks ago, someone joined the boards and outed this woman as an alleged phony. The new board member claimed that the entire story was fictitious and she had some proof via other discussion boards where the unfortunate mother had posted with inconsistencies in her story. Everyone on the LLS Boards seemed to come to the same conclusion: If this woman’s story is true, then it is very tragic. If this woman’s story is fictitious then, thank goodness there is not actually a family carrying such burdens. Finally, everyone seemed to agree that, if she really made up the story, her life is almost equally as sad. Either way, sympathy seemed in order.
Initially, I was somewhat bemused by the whole situation – almost like it was some complex soap opera I was watching. As days went by, I couldn’t shake the story though. I kept returning to the boards, hoping this woman would return and explain herself – explain if any of it was true. Many who have heard this story from me have pointed out that, if she is actually writing fake stories, she could be back already, as a new parent with a new story. I’ve started to feel like the internet is this dark shadowland full of phony stories. And then I remember that my daughter is out there in that shadowland. Photos of her face and her body are available to the crazed, sinister masses. Some of our darkest moments as a family and many of our joys – they are all available and unfiltered.
Usually, from deep inside my anxiety chasm, where I’m sure I’ve permanently sullied my child via internet, I almost always come back to Emma Grace. I see myself sitting at my computer. On the couch, lies our sweet baby, bruised and swollen, angry and pained, implanted with medical devices under her skin, but given a good, fighting prognosis. My child has a good prognosis. My child has cancer. My child has cancer. That’s the name of the discussion board, by the way. My Child Has Cancer. I can put myself back there so easily and I can see those pictures of Emma Grace and I can remember how ravenous I was to read her story. Tell me how the story goes and tell me how it ends, Emma Grace. Tell me about surviving steroids and tell me about how much you love wearing pigtails now. Tell me about how you no longer take narcotic pain medicine and how you are learning how to read and write. Tell me how your teacher praises you for being such a delightful, normal kid, even after nearly three years of cancer treatment. Tell me all about it all and I want details.
I haven’t come to a conclusion about all of this yet. I can’t say that, Yes, I feel 100% confident that I’m doing the right thing by my child. I actually never feel sure about anything, to be honest. Certainly though, I am doing the best that I can. I’m writing and sharing all of this because I really do hope that other parents can sit down, a week after their child’s diagnosis and see Elsa. I want them to see every day of our journey, as much as I want to remember it as well. I want them to see that, in the morning the sun came up and, in the evening, the sun dipped back down and we are still here, having survived the interim. I stay on the LLS boards for much of the same reason. I ache to pay back some of the kindness that we have been shown. I long for this whole shebang (yeah, that’s right, I called cancer a shebang) to have meant something positive – whatever form that may take. If it doesn’t do us some good, then it was suffering for the sake of misery and that seems like an awful lesson to teach my child. I want to show her that we kept trying. Every day, we kept trying and, mixed amongst the grief and fear, we squeezed some fun out too.
Nor can I plead pure altruism here. My writing is very, very selfish, I can assure you. I can hardly understand a word of what goes on in my own head until I’ve written it down. As a child, when I would misbehave, I was always required to submit a formal apology, but I rarely uttered that apology out loud. 10 years old and, unprompted, I would sit myself down on the computer and write until I had myself truly convinced that, Yes, I’m sorry. Somewhere deep inside an 8 inch floppy disk at my father’s house, my apology letters are still paying penance.
My thoughts are jumbled and alarming in their seeming magnitude, until I’ve written them a beginning, middle, and end. I sit back and read and re-read until the whole mess sounds cohesive. Then and only then, as one of my cancer mom friends says, can I hang up my coat after a long day. Unfortunately for Elsa, her life is inextricably intertwined with mine for the near future and my quivering mass of thoughts orbits her as much as it does me.
This feels like it’s only a beginning of a discussion. I’ve really just asked the same question over and over again for 11 paragraphs. Is it OK to write here? Is it OK to feel compelled to bear one’s own soul to both friends and strangers, even if your child’s privacy gets in the way? I’m still asking.

I think that you are creating a priceless memento for Elsa to read someday… you are capturing her brave journey for her as she doesn’t yet have the words to capture it herself… You’re also taking care of yourself by journaling and breathing your experience to life on paper (or computer screen!). I’m sorry that you stumbled upon a stranger out there in internet land with more issues than we care to consider, but your blog isn’t for her, it’s for you, and Elsa. Perhaps someday this blog will turn into a hardcover book for Elsa to share with her babies, or you’ll hear from a publisher who wants you to share Elsa’s triumphs with the world in print! For now, it’s documenting the journey you are on together, as a family. I’m honored to read about such a strong little girl and her very courageous Momma (and Daddy, too!). Keep writing, and we’ll keep praying!
Thanks Catharine! I hope, hope, hope she enjoys reading this some day. Everyone likes to say that she won’t remember any of this, so I think it will be somewhat curious for her to read about all these things that happened to her but that she doesn’t remember. Hopefully!
Obviously I cannot answer your question for you. However, my OPINION is a) writing to my husband about the things he would care about got me through the first year after his death. _I_ found it very therapeutic. b) When _I_ had cancer many people told me I was in their thoughts and prayers. I am very thankful to all of them and shall always be. c) Although I know you only through my son, he was very fond of you and I am concerned. It is impossible while enduring what you are to keep all those who are keeping all y’all in our heart by writing us individually. d) At perhaps age 16 our daughter told me she was going to do either a best-selling book or stand up comedy about MY oddness. I am always chatting with people and she was saying I could never be a drug dealer on the corner because I would want to know if marijuana was a gateway drug, did their family know what they were doing, etc. Now she has daughters I asked if she still felt like writing the book and she said no. When Elsa gets old enough she will appreciate the enormous Horrible Agony you have endured and documentation of blood, sweat, tears will be enduring….unless it isn’t…..ya never know with kids!
And there’s the New Yorker cartoon with the dog saying, “On the Internet no one knows you’re a dog.” You’re on your own there!
Many Best Wishes!
Lynetta
Thanks for the pep talk Lynetta!
I certainly hope Elsa is able to appreciate all this writing for what it is: just her mom’s way of coping and doing the best she can. Hopefully we will raise a thoughtful enough child that, as an adult, she will have a little heart for her poor, old, annoying mom. Probably not until she is a mom herself
hello!! yes! the beginning of a discussion!
i was just thinking about this last night–i saw a facebook and was like, wow, all these babies have a greater internet presence than me, and from day 1. what are the ethics of consent? i don’t think it’ll be weird for them when they grow up, because by then it’ll be so normal.
also–i want to know everything about this possibly false tragedy poster. totally perverse and fascinating!!!
also, here are some unsolicited truisms about the meaning of life, everyone’s favorite subject for truisms. (oh man!) i’m not really a subscriber to the (christian) idea that suffering ennobles us and makes us better. that just doesn’t make sense to me. but i do think that one of the very convenient things about us all suffering so often and sometimes in similar ways is that it allows us to keep each other company–and feeling understood does make us better (and life easier to bear). so i think it’s really important that if you want to, you keep on with blogging–and other forms of communicating–with whomever you can. also, you are so honest and so good at accessing all the feelings and articulating them.
i heard kate visited this weekend. i’m jealous. let’s have a reunion asap!!
This is why we are friends Mego (among many other reasons!). I totally want to know EVERYTHING about this false tragedy poster. I think I am supposed to be angry, since she betrayed our trust – but I just can’t get over how weird and perverse the whole thing is. WHO IS SHE/HE!? Maybe, in the end, she was real and she just feels so hurt for being accused falsely – tough I kind of doubt it. The whole thing is like a melodrama.
I have a lot to write about truisms! But Elsa is proudly announcing that she has poop in her diaper AND she would also like to use the vacuum (ah the mind of a two-year old).
I love you! A1+1 girls weekend is in the works!
Georgia, I can only share my similar experience. When I first ended up with gastroparesis, I found a message board dedicated to the condition. For at least 5 years I read it daily (sometimes multiple times a day) and posted frequently and bared my soul so that my experiences might assist others as well. I found friends of the internet kind there as well. I felt I had to read it as part of some internal ritual. I even edited a newsletter for them. It was the way I coped. I still retain friendship with some of the people I met on this site, but I no longer go to the site. I developed GP in 2003 and now 9 years in, I probably know more about the gastro tract than any lay person should know. GP will always be with me, and I believe I cope pretty damned well with it, but I would not have without the obsessive link I had with the GP site. It allowed me to educate myself, vent, and share information for others like myself. I believe we, too, had an impostor. I think that is just a hazard of the cyber age. Georgia, If it feels good, do it. If it doesn’t, well, stop.
This sounds like it might be a family trait: We are obsessive researchers. The writing, the researching – it all feels good. So, for the time being, I’m sticking with it.
My opinion…….YES. If Elsa doesn’t agree in years to come you can remove it or save it or she can simply not read it. You are doing a wonderful thing and even me, who doesn’t have to live with what your family lives with am grateful because it shows me how blessed I am at this point in my life – to have a healthy child. I also believe that if you touch the lives of just one family ….like Emma Graces story touched you – you are bringing hope…..something so desperately needed in this world. For years I blogged our journey to adopt our little girl from China and questioned myself but it has brought some amazing and special friends and has helped many others as they waited xxx
Yes, Georgia. You should continue to share your thoughts during this journey. Do not let the selfish imaginations of this other mother who faked all her tragedies to gain sympathy affect how you live your life.
You should carry on. Not only because you have the gift of words, and that you need to unburden yourself for your own sanity. But more importantly, because you have a story to share; one that shows us mere mortals how vulnerable we can all be for the curveballs that would otherwise destroy the best of us. Because you’ve shown us how the power of love sustains us in the darkest of times.
As you’ve held on to hope due to the Emma Graces of this world, you can also throw a lifeline to somebody else out there who also need a sliver of hope that there’s light at the end of the tunnel. That one day, all this will come to pass. That’s what we all need: HOPE.
Somebody once questioned the validity of a new technology because of the expenses with sustaining it; those cynics felt that the outcome was not statistically significant. That infuriated me so much, because how can one call even one patient saved not statistically significant. Wouldn’t you want to try everything humanly possible to save even one person?
And that’s why you need to continue with sharing. They are not just ramblings; in the middle of the night when a desperate mother looks for any sign of encouragement, your story will remind her that she is not alone. It might just give her the hope to continue on fighting for her own Elsa.
Thanks for stopping by Jocelyn! It’s so nice to still have this contact with Elmhurst, though I know neither of us is there anymore
I have really been feeling the magnitude of this whole “internet” thing lately – can you imagine what our world was like without Facebook (and that was just a couple years ago!)? I don’t know how I would have endured the past 9 months without the connections I’ve made through the internet. THAT tells me that, amid the scariness, there must be some good. I imagine I would have felt so incredibly alone if this happened to us 10 years ago. Instead, I feel supported, connected, and hopeful. I just have to remind myself of that whenever I’m feeling like the internet is a sinister place.
I wrote a long response and it didn’t post but what I said was YES! If Elsa doesn’t like what you’ve written in years to come you can save it and remove it or she simply doesn’t need to read it.
You story has even touched me ~ my life is so different to yours ~ I don’t have to deal with the things your family does….and your story, Elsa’s story, has helped me see how blessed I am.
I kept a blog for years as we waited to adopt our daughter from China and there were times when I questionned whether I was doing the right thing or not. But I have made some wonderful, supportive friends through my blog…even met a few of them….and I also know my writing has helped those behind me on the journey.
If you story brings hope to one single family….as Emma Grace’s did to you….it is worth it. Hope is something that our world needs.
Good on you for having the courage.~ I truly appreciate you.
Oh no! This happened to another friend of mine with the double comments. I have my comments moderated so that I have to approve them before they pop up on my blog – I was too slow! I think I’ll change it back though. Thank you so much for your kind words of encouragement. I too have enjoyed visiting your blog and getting to know your adorable daughter through your 366 project.
Pretty sure this is going to make me sound like an ass, but your fabricating mother made me think of Fight Club. That part at the beginning where Ed Norton and Helena Bonem Carter meet at some support group for something they need no support for. It looks like this is a thing people really do – in person? On-line? Both? In short, your discomfort with writing about Elsa is understandable, but it’s quite clear that this blog has a lot going for it. For you, for other parents, for your friends (who need fewer individual updates this way), and – yes – for Elsa. She’ll want to know about all this one day. You’re doing good Georgia, so keep writing.
Thanks Amanda
I can’t tell if I am being an awful person or not, but it really does help when people tell me that I am doing an OK thing. And a lot of people have mentioned: By the time Elsa is older, this will be a non-issue because every kid on earth will have an internet presence that is pages and pages long. Not sure if that is a good thing, but I think it probably is the reality of where we are heading.
Also: Now I must go watch Fight Club again. I’m pretty sure the last time I saw it, I was still sharing a 12x12ft dorm room with you.
I just wrote a longish comment re: Fight Club and the support group tourism and how your fabricating mother is like them, but it seems to have vanished.
Basically, yes. They writing is good for you, us, and Elsa too. She’ll want to know about all this.
Oh no! This has happened twice now. I have my comments set so that I have to “approve” them first and I hadn’t yet approved your first one. But now you have left two and that is twice as nice!
I…just – What is the medical name for this type of psychological illness? Something akin to internet Munchausen’s or something? Agree that sympathy is in order for the woman one way or another.
As for you – there are ways to continue to write but limit access to the blog. You can make it so that only people with the link will find it. I understand your internal debate, ultimately I stopped blogging because I didn’t have the confidence to continue, and wanted to remain anonymous. I think you can have your cake and eat it, too. I also relate to the therapeutic process of writing, organizing thoughts. It helps with my anxiety, too. When things are just too awful and I can’t make sense of my emotions or my life, writing helps arrange them in a way that is no longer abstract. To sum it up, keep writing. Block the blog from google if you want. You write well, you convey so much emotion. I have no idea what you and your family are going through, but by the time I’m done reading, you have written so beautifully that you’ve convinced me for those few minutes that I do know what you’re going through.
Keep your head up, girl.
Elsa is someone’s Emma Grace. Keep going.
[...] story and whether or not it is OK to have shared our life so openly. I wrote about it this before so I suppose this is like my Chapter Two to the question of whether or not I’m going to keep [...]
[...] story and whether or not it is OK to have shared our life so openly. I wrote about it this before so I suppose this is like my Chapter Two to the question of whether or not I’m going to keep [...]